NYVIC (New Yorkers for Vaccination Information and Choice)


(3/99 Note: The legislation referred to below was before Congress in 1995.  Unfortunately, the concerns expressed here are, no doubt, still warranted.)

Why There is a Need for Natural Immunity Legislation

Bills in Congress

TO: People who practice or advocate any health care or lifestyle approach in addition to or instead of what is sanctioned by the modern medical establishment (i.e.: herbal and homeopathic remedies home births, extended breast feeding, vegetarian diets, the family bed, home education, et cetera)

RE: Two bills introduced into the House (H.R. 1946; sponsor Mr. Largent) and Senate (S 984; sponsor Mr. Grassley) entitled "The Parental Rights and Responsibilities Act of 1995"


On the surface, these bills appear to restrain the government from interfering in the fundamental rights of parents to raise and care for their children. The wording implies allowances for differences in parenting philosophies but warns that action will be taken against parents if there is "compelling justification".

The reference standard for determining "justification'' for governmental "interference or usurpation" is "the tradition of western civilization". These bills attempt to protect children from their parents' "abuse and neglect" as "traditionally defined and applied in State Law". The bills purport to preserve parental choices in health care decisions "unless, by neglect or refusal, the parental decision will result in danger to the life of the child or result in serious physical injury to the child".

Growing numbers of doctors and anonymous people have registered charges of child abuse and neglect or medical neglect with state agencies against well-informed parents who have avoided specific modern medical treatments which have been shown to "result in danger to the life of the child or result in serious physical injury to the child ". In my experience, the standards used in courts to determine the validity of these charges are slanted heavily in favor of modern medical practice and common belief, both spawned by industry and media influence.

In cases with which I am familiar, without cause, exemplary parents have lost custody of their children either temporarily or permanently; children have been vaccinated while under the temporary guardianship of Commissioners of Health; children have been placed in foster care for indeterminate periods with very limited visitation disrupting breast feeding. In cases where children were allowed to remain at home, parents have been ordered to wean them, feed their vegetarian children meat, consent to modern medical drugging including vaccination, chemotherapy, and invasive testing. Courts have determined that parents were putting their children at unnecessary risk in spite of scientific and medical reports which supported these parents' choices.

When pregnant women consider foregoing invasive screening and monitoring they, too, are threatened with court action. Loss of custody is used to coerce parents to consent to vaccination against their will, convictions, & better judgment, causing irreparable rifts between spouses.

The language of these bills is very vague leaving ample room for those in political power, via election and appointment, to misinterpret and possibly violate our birthrights even further. We must speak out to either dismantle these bills or to infuse some wisdom into the standard definition of "neglect and abuse", and put compassion, understanding, sensitivity, careful observation and perspective into the view of health care. I believe that setting a national standard of this type will step up the monitoring and oversight powers of state agencies in these areas causing increased illness, injury, strife, divorce, and even death.

http://www.nolo.com/ChunkLR/LR.index.html How to Find Your State Statutes Online
http://www.findlaw.com Legal Research Findlaw search engine

Back to New York State Law



What is the future of our Vaccination Decisions Support Group? Answers, (such as they are) will be posted here.

Audio and Video Vaccination Related Links

Trading chickenpox for shingles? Research published in the International Journal of Toxicology. 



   Search   Health & Disease   Law   News   Support   Resources   Latest pages   Forum   Subscribe to Updates

Contact New Yorkers for Vaccination Information and Choice